Coney Island Restaurant in Mansfield, OH review

Coney Island Restaurant in Mansfield, Ohio review

Coney Island Restaurant in Mansfield, Ohio review

I’ve been eating coneys from this place for as long as I can remember; so basically I’ve pretty much been growing up on them!  :)  They’re SO delicious and really unlike any other coney I’ve ever had and I’m pretty much an expert when it comes to them!  :)

Coney Island Restaurant is located in my hometown and their coneys have always been a treat that my dad would pick up on his way home from work.  Yes, you can get carry out!  :)  You basically just walk in there and ask for a “baker’s dozen” and you’ll walk out with a bag full of 13 coneys where you can snack on one on the way home and no one would ever know.  I mean, why would a coney shop sell coneys by 13?  :)  Shhh…  :)

I know many locals that actually eat inside Coney Island, but this is something I can’t vouch for because I know there’s not a lot of room inside the establishment.  However, it’s very much like an old school diner!  :)

The trick?  You have to add pepper to them JUST before eating.  I know, that sounds weird, however it makes all the difference, I promise!  And I know 13 coneys are a lot, but they honestly warm up well in the microwave the next day!

Ever strolling through Mansfield?  Check out this gem; you won’t be disappointed!

Newsletter

You Might Also Like

  • Lora Cotton

    If this place is anything like Phillip’s Coney Island in Columbus, Ohio, you DO have a REAL gem there!!! I’m originally from the extreme far west-side of Columbus and quite frankly can’t wait to get back there!!! (I’m currently and for the immediate future in Houston TX.) You’ve got my mouth watering for an honest to goodness Coney!!!

    • I have never heard of Phillips! I’ll have to check it out!

      • Lora Cotton

        They are located on West Broad Street, near the Spaghetti Warehouse. If you are in front of the S.H. you want to go just a little further west (like as far as past the railroad viaduct, cause the Phillips is the very next building on the north side of the broad.) They do have kinda strange hours (they close relatively early) so make sure you go earlier in the day or early evening. They’ve been in Cols for ions!!!

        Since I’ve been away from Ohio for 5 yrs now, I did a quick search and found that they ARE STILL in the same spot, and they are billed as Phillips Original Coney Island, located in “Franklinton.” There were several listings for them on sites such as Yelp, grubhub, etc.

        • OH how interesting! I think I may have to take a trip to Columbus soon! :)

  • ashley @ sunnysideshlee.com

    this makes me hungry.

Send this to a friend