Coney Island Restaurant in Mansfield, Ohio review
I’ve been eating coneys from this place for as long as I can remember; so basically I’ve pretty much been growing up on them! :) They’re SO delicious and really unlike any other coney I’ve ever had and I’m pretty much an expert when it comes to them! :)
Coney Island Restaurant is located in my hometown and their coneys have always been a treat that my dad would pick up on his way home from work. Yes, you can get carry out! :) You basically just walk in there and ask for a “baker’s dozen” and you’ll walk out with a bag full of 13 coneys where you can snack on one on the way home and no one would ever know. I mean, why would a coney shop sell coneys by 13? :) Shhh… :)
I know many locals that actually eat inside Coney Island, but this is something I can’t vouch for because I know there’s not a lot of room inside the establishment. However, it’s very much like an old school diner! :)
The trick? You have to add pepper to them JUST before eating. I know, that sounds weird, however it makes all the difference, I promise! And I know 13 coneys are a lot, but they honestly warm up well in the microwave the next day!
Ever strolling through Mansfield? Check out this gem; you won’t be disappointed!